On the moral significance of contribution to poverty
General Material Designation
[Article]
First Statement of Responsibility
/ Jorn Sonderholm
GENERAL NOTES
Text of Note
9626-1744
SUMMARY OR ABSTRACT
Text of Note
In a paper from 2005, Gerhard Overland defends the thesis that one's responsibility to render assistance is not affected by having contributed to the situation by causing harm. Overland applies this thesis to the issue of what duties relatively welloff people have in terms of rendering assistance to the global poor and argues for the subconclusion that contribution carries little momentum when assessing our duty to assist people in severe need if we can do so at a little cost. In this paper, I discuss Overland's argument in favor of the subconclusion and try to show that it is not sound.