Metaethics -- Two arguments for sentimentalism / Justin D'Arms -- The open question argument : what it isn't; and what it is / Fred Feldman -- Moral particularism and transduction / Gilbert Harman -- Moral phenomenology and moral theory / Terry Horgan and Mark Timmons -- The Frege-Geach point / Paul Horwich -- What are cognitivists doing when they do normative ethics? / Frank Jackson -- Error theory and the possibility of normative ethics / Russ Shafer-Landau -- Normative ethics -- Wrongs within rights / Robert Audi -- Ross and utilitarianism on promise keeping and lying : self-evidence and the data of ethics / Thomas L. Carson -- Assessing moral rules : utilitarian and Kantian perspectives / Thomas E. Hill, Jr. -- Kantian fairness / George Sher -- You ought to be ashamed of yourself )when you violate an imperfect moral obligation( / Walter Sinnott-Armstrong -- The dualism of the ethical / Michael Slote -- A "new" principle of aggregation / Larry Temkin -- Book symposium on Brad Hooker's Ideal code, real world -- Sophisticated rule consequentialism : some simple objections / Richard Arneson -- The perils of holism : Brad Hooker's Ideal code, real world / Alison McIntyre -- Reply to Arneson and McIntyre / Brad Hooker -- Content and normativity -- How it is not "just like diabetes" : mental disorders and the moral psychologist / Nomy Arpaly -- A new map of theories of mental content : locating normative theories / Mark Greenberg -- Rationality and truth -- Does rationality give us reasons / John Broome -- Truth and correct belief / Allan Gibbard -- Applied ethics and political philosophy -- Political authority and the tyranny of non-consent / David Estlund -- Moral arrogance and moral theories / Bernard Gert -- The basis of moral liability to defensive killing / Jeff McMahan