The question of who compiled Ad Quirinum remains unresolved. The previous consensus that it was indeed Cyprian, based largely on Koch's work, was challenged by Bobertz over twenty years ago. Since then, the issue has received little attention. Here I refute Bobertz's main arguments for believing that the collection existed prior to Cyprian's conversion. I argue that textual variations between Ad Quirinum and Cyprian's letters and treatises do not rule out Cyprian being the compiler, as similar variations also occur in Cyprian's uncontested works. I examine the role of tradition and memory in scriptural citation and show how Cyprian's own catechumenate assisted in his preparation of Ad Quirinum. I also demonstrate that there is no conflict between Test. 3.28 and Cyprian's practice in the wake of the Decian persecution and consider why Pontius did not include the work in his list of treatises. The question of who compiled Ad Quirinum remains unresolved. The previous consensus that it was indeed Cyprian, based largely on Koch's work, was challenged by Bobertz over twenty years ago. Since then, the issue has received little attention. Here I refute Bobertz's main arguments for believing that the collection existed prior to Cyprian's conversion. I argue that textual variations between Ad Quirinum and Cyprian's letters and treatises do not rule out Cyprian being the compiler, as similar variations also occur in Cyprian's uncontested works. I examine the role of tradition and memory in scriptural citation and show how Cyprian's own catechumenate assisted in his preparation of Ad Quirinum. I also demonstrate that there is no conflict between Test. 3.28 and Cyprian's practice in the wake of the Decian persecution and consider why Pontius did not include the work in his list of treatises.
مجموعه
تاريخ نشر
2014
توصيف ظاهري
533-550
عنوان
Vigiliae Christianae
شماره جلد
68/5
شماره استاندارد بين المللي پياييندها
1570-0720
اصطلاحهای موضوعی کنترل نشده
اصطلاح موضوعی
Ad Quirinum
اصطلاح موضوعی
Bobertz
اصطلاح موضوعی
Cyprian
اصطلاح موضوعی
scriptural citation
اصطلاح موضوعی
testimonia
اصطلاح موضوعی
tradition
نام شخص به منزله سر شناسه - (مسئولیت معنوی درجه اول )