Despite the apparently irreconcilable conflict between 'pro-life' and 'pro-choice' activists in the abortion debate, many feminists and Catholic theologians agree that questions of consciousness, relationality and foetal development are of greater ethical significance than theological claims about the personhood of the embryo or feminist claims about women's autonomy. This article argues that absolutist positions based on the embryo's right to life or the woman's right to choose fail to represent the reality of abortion and the dilemmas it poses. It suggests an approach in which maternal consciousness and foetal development are together recognized as intrinsic to the process of humanization, and argues for a gradual shift in emphasis from the primacy of the woman's right to choose in the first trimester, to the right to life of the foetus in the third semester. It concludes with a reflection on Mary and Eve, as symbols of women's eschatological hope and existential reality with regard to childbearing. Despite the apparently irreconcilable conflict between 'pro-life' and 'pro-choice' activists in the abortion debate, many feminists and Catholic theologians agree that questions of consciousness, relationality and foetal development are of greater ethical significance than theological claims about the personhood of the embryo or feminist claims about women's autonomy. This article argues that absolutist positions based on the embryo's right to life or the woman's right to choose fail to represent the reality of abortion and the dilemmas it poses. It suggests an approach in which maternal consciousness and foetal development are together recognized as intrinsic to the process of humanization, and argues for a gradual shift in emphasis from the primacy of the woman's right to choose in the first trimester, to the right to life of the foetus in the third semester. It concludes with a reflection on Mary and Eve, as symbols of women's eschatological hope and existential reality with regard to childbearing.
مجموعه
تاريخ نشر
2009
توصيف ظاهري
51-75
عنوان
International Journal of Public Theology
شماره جلد
4/1
شماره استاندارد بين المللي پياييندها
1569-7320
اصطلاحهای موضوعی کنترل نشده
اصطلاح موضوعی
abortion
اصطلاح موضوعی
Caritas in Veritate
اصطلاح موضوعی
feminism
اصطلاح موضوعی
personhood
اصطلاح موضوعی
pro-choice
اصطلاح موضوعی
pro-life
اصطلاح موضوعی
Roman Catholicism
نام شخص به منزله سر شناسه - (مسئولیت معنوی درجه اول )