عنوان
پدید آورنده
موضوع
رده
کتابخانه
محل استقرار
NATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHY NUMBER
Number
LA116332
LANGUAGE OF THE ITEM
.Language of Text, Soundtrack etc
انگلیسی
TITLE AND STATEMENT OF RESPONSIBILITY
Title Proper
A Critical Analysis of Firestone's Hypothesis Regarding the Qurʾānic Legislation on Holy War
General Material Designation
[Article]
First Statement of Responsibility
Mohammad Ali Tabataba'i, Maryam Velayati, Mohammad Ali Tabataba'i, et al.
.PUBLICATION, DISTRIBUTION, ETC
Place of Publication, Distribution, etc.
Leiden
Name of Publisher, Distributor, etc.
Brill
SUMMARY OR ABSTRACT
Text of Note
Reuven Firestone in his works on the concept of holy war in Islam has criticized the traditional resolution for the problem of disparity between the Qurʾānic verses on war and suggested a new interpretation of the relationship between the verses. This paper aims to reevaluate Firestone's contribution by taking a closer look at his critique of the traditional theory as well as his alternative suggestion. This study shows that what Firestone attributes to the Muslim tradition is a mistaken projection of some modern views onto the early authorities. The ambivalent stance of Firestone towards the historicity of the early Muslim literature results in a loose hypothesis regarding the formation of the Qurʾānic verses on war which neither meets the traditional specifications, nor satisfies the criteria of the skeptic party of Islamicists. Reuven Firestone in his works on the concept of holy war in Islam has criticized the traditional resolution for the problem of disparity between the Qurʾānic verses on war and suggested a new interpretation of the relationship between the verses. This paper aims to reevaluate Firestone's contribution by taking a closer look at his critique of the traditional theory as well as his alternative suggestion. This study shows that what Firestone attributes to the Muslim tradition is a mistaken projection of some modern views onto the early authorities. The ambivalent stance of Firestone towards the historicity of the early Muslim literature results in a loose hypothesis regarding the formation of the Qurʾānic verses on war which neither meets the traditional specifications, nor satisfies the criteria of the skeptic party of Islamicists.
SET
Date of Publication
2019
Physical description
147-167
Title
Al-Bayan: Journal of Qur'an and Hadith Studies
Volume Number
17/2
International Standard Serial Number
2232-1969
UNCONTROLLED SUBJECT TERMS
Subject Term
abrogation
Subject Term
exegesis (tafsīr)
Subject Term
jihad
Subject Term
Qurʾān
Subject Term
Reuven Firestone
Subject Term
war
PERSONAL NAME - PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY
Maryam Velayati
Mohammad Ali Tabataba'i
LOCATION AND CALL NUMBER
Call Number
10.1163/22321969-12340072
ELECTRONIC LOCATION AND ACCESS
Electronic name
مطالعه متن کتاب p
[Article]
275578
a
Y
