This paper responds to critiques of my Philosophy and the Study of Religions: A Manifesto (Blackwell, 2014) from Jeppe Jensen, Mark Gardiner, Bryan Rennie, and Kenneth MacKendrick. It aims to defend my book's proposals in such a way as to nudge the discipline of philosophy of religion into a reflexive mode that might be called "philosophy of religion studies." This paper responds to critiques of my Philosophy and the Study of Religions: A Manifesto (Blackwell, 2014) from Jeppe Jensen, Mark Gardiner, Bryan Rennie, and Kenneth MacKendrick. It aims to defend my book's proposals in such a way as to nudge the discipline of philosophy of religion into a reflexive mode that might be called "philosophy of religion studies."